Friday, 14 November 2008

England need Swann, amongst many things

It was as if the incredible 4-0 thumping of South Africa never happened, as England endured a humiliating loss in the first of their seven ODIs in India. England were excellent against South Africa; but they paid the price for stubbornly sticking to the formula that was so successful then. In vastly different conditions, different approaches are needed.

Most fundamentally, England blundered badly in failing to select Graeme Swann. Swann had a very good series against New Zealand in the summer, was extremely unfortunate to be dropped for Samit Patel, and his stats show he should be regarded as England's premier one-day spinner. that is not to say Patel does not have a role to play; but, despite his five wicket haul in the third ODI against South Africa, he is a batting allrounder who should be regarded as the fifth or six bowler. England need both Swann and Patel in these conditions.

Though Ravi Bopara gave a long overdue reminder of his talent, it is bewildering that there is no place even in the squad for Dimitri Mascharenhas. He offers remarkable six-hitting capacity at number eight, canny bowling that could be well-suited to these wickets, smart fielding and a shrewd cricketing brain. Mascharenhas is a fine cricketer and has already done enough to suggest he could have a vital role to play for England.

The opening partnership of Matt Prior and Ian Bell excelled against South Africa, but it feels knee-jerk to critice it so soon on the tour. But, in Indian conditions power hitting, of the sort exhibited by Virender Sehwag, is needed from the off. Prior, the supossed aggressor, may be better utilised lower down the order. But England, having injudiciously selected Cook as the reserve batsman, have few options. They must adapt to survive - select two spinners and show a willingness to tinker with the batting order.


Richard Lake said...

To be honest I'm not sure what Bopara's doing there. He didn't bowl and to bring him in at 8 seems to be a waste.

I agree Swann should play, and a decision made between Bopara and Patel (I'd go with Patel on current form). Bopara's brainless running ceratinly won't help his cause.

As for the openers, we play our own way, but it does require that we don't lose a flurry of wickets at the start of the innings.

Soulberry said...

Bopara is the best England batsman after KP.

After this series, there will no longer be any doubts, provided he is played in all games.

Patel, I'm sorry to say, will not matter greatly this tour. Monty might and Bopara will leave an impression.

Now I sit back to have my words come and bite me...or maybe purr and rub against my leg like a tamed kitty.

wildkiwi23 said...

Hi there,

Just come across your site when I was searching for other cricket blogs on Google. Your site is one I would definetly consider to having a high standard, I can say I would defiently be reading it from time to time!

I also have a cricket site of my own I would highly recommend you having a look at. It is called "Cricket, the Brilliant Game" and the web address for it is If you are also interested in doing a link exchange with me feel free to email your site's details to my email at, and when you add my site please use the following details:

Site Name: Cricket, the Brilliant Game!
Web Address:
Link name: Cricket, the Brilliant Game!

Also email me when you have added me so I can add your site on mine promptly.



basroy said...

Shop smart for the best car deals online. When you are shopping for a car online beware of fraudulent vehicle sales. Use trusted car buying sites like eBay Motors. Don't pay for a vehicle online using a wire service. Get more tips to protect yourself and your money.Engine Coolant Is A Year Round Concern so make sure you check your car's coolant levels on a regular basis. Antifreeze/coolant keeps your engine's cooling system from boiling over in the heat and freezing in the cold.Underground Racing is all about speed and supercars. Find out more about this Charlotte, NC based tuner shop that specializes in custom-built turbocharing and supercharging systems.

Mercedes Benz 260E Power Steering Gearbox